I have gone back to reading Auden; this time I am reading his prose in The Dyer’s Hand. He has much to say about life and old age, but I was particularly taken by this bit about Narcissus:
Narcissus does not fall in love with his reflection because it is beautiful, but because it is his. If it were his beauty that enthralled him, he would be set free in a few years by its fading.
We love our image because it is ours; we even correct it in our minds to be closer to what we think it should be. I always think I look better in the mirror than I do in the cell phone pictures people take – I guess it is harder to mentally photoshop pixels than it is a face in the mirror (or in the mind).
Auden’s love for his own old body extended to his old age, even though he himself described his face as “a wedding cake that had been left out in the rain.” It was his. This comes across in his poem “A Lullaby,” written a year before he died. Here he hugs himself, calls himself “Big Baby,” and references Narcissus again:
The old Greeks got it all wrong:
Narcissus is an oldie,
tamed by time, released at last
from lust for other bodies,
rational and reconciled.
For many years you envied
the hirsute, the he-man type.
No longer: now you fondle
your almost feminine flesh
with mettled satisfaction….
Harold Bloom loved this poem: “Older than Auden was [when he wrote the poem], I chant this lullaby to myself during sleepless nights and wish I had more of his admirable temperament.”
Bloom is right; Auden did have an “admirable temperament,” even in his old age (although Auden only lived to age sixty-six). Like Spinoza, Auden thought we all have a duty to be cheerful, to be happy (again, from The Dyer’s Hand):
It is incorrect to say, as the Declaration of Independence says, that all men have a right to the pursuit of happiness. All men have a right to avoid unnecessary pain if they can, and no man has a right to pleasure at the cost of another’s pain. But happiness is not a right; it is a duty. To the degree that we are unhappy, we are in sin. (And vice versa.) A duty cannot be pursued because its imperative applies to the present instant, not to some future date.
My duty toward God is to be happy; my duty towards my neighbor is to try my best to give him pleasure and alleviate his pain. No human being can make another one happy.
Spinoza did not put it in religious terms; in his Ethics, he tried to reason his way through to a formula for the good life and says this: “Cheerfulness cannot be excessive, but is always good; melancholy, on the other hand, is always evil.” And Spinoza has no use for regrets, the one thing that often heads off happiness in old age: “Repentance is not a virtue… instead, he who repents what he has done is twice wretched.”
Auden quotes Caesare Paves on the definition of maturity: One ceases to be a child when one realizes that telling one’s trouble does not make it any better. Auden does not think that it even does any good to tell ourselves about our trouble. Love the old body, love the life you have had and have now, and do your duty to be happy. So says Auden, but it is not easy.
However, there are moments, like the one my character has in “Snickerdoodles.”